Can a cheaper electric vehicle really go as far as its pricier sibling? The Indian EV market is curious about this. Mahindra has launched two electric SUVs with similar features.
The Mahindra XEV9E vs BE6 range test shows surprising results. The XEV9E starts at Rs 21.90 lakh, while the BE6 is priced at Rs 18.90 lakh. Both promise ranges of 542-683 kilometers, as certified by ARAI.
This comparison looks at how these EVs perform in real life, not just in labs. The XEV9E has 59-79 kWh battery options and can charge up to 180 kW DC fast. The BE6 has the same battery sizes but charges at 140 kW DC. Both can get to 80% charge in 20 minutes.
But how do they do on the road? The XEV9E gets 430-460 kilometers in real driving, users say. This comparison aims to find out which EV offers the best value for Indian buyers looking for practical electric cars.
Key Takeaways
- The BE6 claims slightly higher ARAI range (557-683 km) compared to XEV9E (542-656 km) despite lower price
- Real-world XEV9E range drops to 430-460 km in mixed driving conditions
- Both EVs feature identical battery options from 59 kWh to 79 kWh capacity
- Fast charging reaches 80% in 20 minutes for both models
- XEV9E supports 180 kW DC charging while BE6 manages 140 kW DC
- Price difference of Rs 3 lakh between base variants favors the BE6
Introduction to Electric Vehicle Range Tests
Range testing is key to figuring out how far electric vehicles can go on one charge. It shows how far an EV can travel, giving buyers real-world info. This helps them choose the right car based on electric vehicle performance.
What is Range Testing?
Range testing checks how well an electric vehicle’s battery works. The Automotive Research Association of India (ARAI) does these tests. They follow strict rules to get official range numbers.
But, real-world driving is different from lab tests. Things like traffic, air conditioning, and how you drive affect the range. Most EVs don’t go as far as ARAI says. For example, the Mahindra XEV 9e might go 430 to 460 kilometers, not 542 to 656 as ARAI claims.
Importance of Range in EV Selection
Range anxiety is a big worry for EV buyers in India. It’s important for daily commutes and occasional long trips. An EV efficiency comparison helps find the best car for your needs.
City drivers and those who travel long distances have different needs. Knowing how far an EV can really go helps choose the right car. This way, buyers avoid surprises and find a car that fits their life.
Overview of Mahindra XEV9E
The Mahindra XEV9E is a strong contender in the electric vehicle market. It combines advanced technology with a design that appeals to today’s drivers. This electric SUV is built on Mahindra’s electric platform, showing the brand’s commitment to premium electric mobility in India.
Key Features and Specifications
The XEV9E has impressive technical specs, making it stand out in the market. It has a Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor that produces 282 horsepower and 380 Newton-meters of torque. It comes with two battery options: 59 kWh for daily use and 79 kWh for longer trips.
The SUV is 4,789mm long, 1,907mm wide, and 1,694mm tall. It has a 2,775mm wheelbase for spacious interiors and 207mm ground clearance for Indian roads. It has a single-speed automatic transmission and rear-wheel drive for better efficiency.
Design and Comfort
The interior features three 12.3-inch screens for a digital cockpit. It also has a 16-speaker Harman/Kardon audio system with Dolby Atmos. A panoramic glass roof adds natural light, making the interior bright and airy for five people.
| Comfort Features | Details |
|---|---|
| Seating Configuration | 5-seater with ventilated front seats |
| Climate Control | 2-zone automatic temperature management |
| Charging Options | Wireless charging pad for devices |
| Storage Capacity | 663-liter boot space |
Battery and Performance Metrics
The XEV9E has a 5-star BNCAP safety rating. It comes with six airbags, Level 2 ADAS technology, and a 360-degree camera system. These features enhance its performance in real-world driving. The battery management system ensures consistent performance and long battery life.
Overview of BE6
The BE6 is a top choice in the electric vehicle market. It combines great performance with everyday practicality. This compact SUV has impressive specs, making it perfect for those who need reliable range and the latest tech.
It comes with two battery choices and cutting-edge tech. This makes the BE6 ideal for drivers who want both efficiency and fun on their daily drives.
Key Features and Specifications
The BE6 has a Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor. It produces 228 bhp and 380 Nm of torque. This motor allows the BE6 to go from 0-100 kmph in 6.7 seconds and reach a top speed of 202 kmph.
There are two battery options: 59 kWh and 79 kWh. This gives buyers flexibility based on their driving habits and budget.
Design and Comfort
The BE6 is 4371mm long, 1907mm wide, and 1627mm tall. It has a spacious cabin despite its compact size. The 2775mm wheelbase ensures room for five passengers.
It also has 207mm of ground clearance, perfect for Indian roads. Notable comfort features include a 16-speaker Dolby Atmos sound system, ambient lighting, and ORMS technology. The 455-liter boot is great for carrying stuff on trips.
Battery and Performance Metrics
In the EV range comparison, the BE6 gets between 557-683 km per charge. ARAI testing standards confirm this. It has five drive modes to suit different needs.
Range mode boosts distance, Race mode gives full power, and Everyday mode is for daily use. Snow and Custom modes adjust to specific conditions.
| Battery Option | ARAI Range | Power Output |
|---|---|---|
| 59 kWh | 557 km | 170 kW |
| 79 kWh | 683 km | 170 kW |
Testing Methods for Range
Manufacturers test electric vehicles in labs and real-world settings. The Mahindra XEV9E vs BE6 Range Test shows big differences between official numbers and real driving. Tests range from controlled labs to everyday roads.
Standardized Testing Procedures
The Automotive Research Association of India (ARAI) tests range in labs. They measure energy use under certain conditions. This way, they figure out range based on battery size. It’s done without wind, traffic, or how the driver acts.
ARAI tests give optimistic figures compared to real driving. The XEV9E gets 542-656 km in lab tests, and the BE6 does too. But these tests don’t always match real-world driving.
Real-World Driving Conditions
Real electric vehicle performance is affected by many things labs can’t test. Driving in cities, on highways, and in stop-and-go traffic matters. Weather also affects how far you can go.
| Testing Factor | Impact on Range | XEV9E Real Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature Extremes | 15-25% reduction | 430-460 km achieved |
| Terrain Changes | 10-20% variation | Regenerative braking helps |
| Driving Style | 20-30% difference | 4-level regen modes |
Both cars have regenerative braking with four levels. The XEV9E charges up to 80% in 20 minutes with 180 kW DC fast charging. The BE6 charges at 140 kW, with similar times.
Performance Results: Mahindra XEV9E
The Mahindra XEV9E shows great results in our electric vehicle range test. It highlights the skills of modern Indian EV engineering. Testing it in real-world conditions shows how it performs under different conditions and battery sizes.
Total Range Achieved
The XEV9E comes with two battery sizes. The 59 kWh battery gets you 542 kilometers, as ARAI says. The bigger 79 kWh battery boosts this to 656 kilometers. But, real-world driving shows a different picture.
In mixed driving, you can expect 430 to 460 kilometers. This is about 70 to 80 percent of what’s advertised.
Factors Affecting Performance
Many things affect the XEV9E’s performance:
- Driving style – Fast driving cuts range by up to 20 percent
- Climate control – Using air conditioning reduces range by about 15 percent
- Terrain variations – Going up hills makes it less efficient
- Vehicle payload – Carrying more people and stuff uses more battery
- Drive modes – You can choose settings to save energy or go fast
Comparisons with Manufacturer Claims
The difference between ARAI ratings and real-world results is common. The Pack Three has a 282 bhp motor for fast starts but uses more energy. Charging is fast, with DC fast charging to 80 percent in 20 minutes at 180 kW stations.
Standard AC charging takes 8 to 11.7 hours. This depends on the charger’s power, 7.2 kW or 11.2 kW.
Performance Results: BE6
The BE6 electric SUV stands out in the Mahindra vs BE6 electric vehicle range testing. It shows top-notch performance that beats many expectations. Tests show it can keep a steady range in various driving conditions and stays efficient.
Total Range Achieved
The BE6 has two battery options, both showing great range. The 59 kWh battery gets 557 kilometers, as certified by ARAI. The bigger 79 kWh battery goes up to 683 kilometers on one charge. Surprisingly, the Batman Edition with the 59 kWh battery also hits 683 kilometers, thanks to smart efficiency.
Factors Affecting Performance
Several things help the BE6 achieve its impressive range:
- Its lighter weight at 2,070 kg helps it use energy better
- The 228 bhp motor gives good power without using too much energy
- Five drive modes let drivers choose between range or speed
- Range mode boosts distance by adjusting the throttle
- Its design cuts down on drag at high speeds
Comparisons with Manufacturer Claims
Real-world tests show the BE6 lives up to its promises. It accelerates from 0-100 kmph in 6.7 seconds, proving its speed. It also charges fast, reaching 80% in 20 minutes with 140 kW chargers. AC charging takes 6 to 8.7 hours, depending on the charger used.
Head-to-Head Comparison
When we compare the Mahindra XEV9E and BE6, we find some surprising results. These two models show different ways to improve efficiency and range in the Indian EV market.
Side-by-Side Range Analysis
The BE6 leads with a 683 km ARAI-certified range from its 79 kWh battery pack. The XEV9E gets 656 km with the same battery, 27 km less. This is important for those who drive long distances.
| Specification | Mahindra XEV9E | BE6 |
|---|---|---|
| ARAI Range | 656 km | 683 km |
| Battery Capacity | 79 kWh | 79 kWh |
| Power Output | 282 bhp | 228 bhp |
| DC Fast Charging | 180 kW | 140 kW |
| Drivetrain | RWD Single-speed | RWD Single-speed |
Performance Under Similar Conditions
In real-world tests, both cars see a 15-30% drop from their ARAI ranges. The BE6’s lighter build helps it perform better. The XEV9E makes up for it with quicker charging, cutting down on wait times. Both have identical CCS-II charging ports, making them compatible with India’s charging network.
Cost of Ownership
When looking at the Mahindra XEV9E vs BE6 Range Test, the cost is key. The total cost of owning a car is more than just the price. It includes how much you spend on running the car every day.
Initial Purchase Prices
The BE6 starts at Rs 18.90 lakh, making it cheaper. The XEV9E costs Rs 21.90 lakh, which is Rs 3 lakh more. For those wanting the best, the XEV9E Pack Three costs Rs 31.25 lakh.
The BE6 Batman Edition is Rs 27.79 lakh. It’s a special edition that’s cheaper than the XEV9E’s top model.
Ongoing Costs: Charging and Maintenance
Both cars save money on running costs. They both support home charging with 7.2 kW or 11.2 kW AC chargers. This means similar costs for daily use.
Both makers offer five-year free service packages. This helps cut down on maintenance costs right from the start.
| Cost Factor | Mahindra XEV9E | BE6 |
|---|---|---|
| Base Price | Rs 21.90 lakh | Rs 18.90 lakh |
| Top Variant | Rs 31.25 lakh | Rs 27.79 lakh |
| Free Service Period | 5 years | 5 years |
| Home Charging Options | 7.2/11.2 kW | 7.2/11.2 kW |
Electric cars don’t need oil changes and use regenerative braking. This makes brake pads last longer. Insurance for the XEV9E is higher because it’s more expensive.
Both cars get government subsidies and tax benefits. This helps lower the cost of buying them.
Conclusion: Which EV is the Better Choice?
The electric vehicle range test shows each model has its own strengths. The BE6 leads with a certified range of 683 kilometers. This is 27 kilometers more than the XEV9E’s top variant range of 656 kilometers.
This difference makes the BE6 better for those who want to travel far without needing to charge often.
Summary of Key Findings
The BE6 has a lower starting price, Rs 3 lakh less than the XEV9E. This makes electric cars more affordable for Indian buyers. Its design and range are appealing to those looking for value.
The XEV9E offers more space, with a huge 663-liter boot and a long body. This makes it great for families who need room for everyone.
Both cars have 5-star BNCAP safety ratings and advanced ADAS technology. The XEV9E charges faster, which is good for long trips. It also has premium features like triple screens and Harman/Kardon audio.
Real-world tests show both cars can go 430-460 kilometers on Indian roads. This meets most daily driving needs.
Recommendations for Future Buyers
The BE6 is perfect for single professionals and couples. It offers great range, sporty looks, and value. Its lower price and better range make it great for first-time EV buyers.
The XEV9E is better for families. It has more space, comfort, and premium features. Mahindra’s wide service network in India supports both models, ensuring a good ownership experience.
Leave a Reply